OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Allah rape maaf kar sakta hai, lekin murti puja nahi?
Ek Sanatani objector ne hypothetical situation uthai:
“Mere samne do khuda hain — ek kehta hai ke murti puja mat karo, lekin rape kabhi maaf nahi hoga. Dusra kehta hai ke rape to maaf ho sakta hai, murti puja nahi.”
Uska sawaal tha: “In dono me se kaun sa khuda sahi hai? Aur kya Islam sach me rape ko maaf kar sakta hai lekin shirk ko nahi?”
SHORT ANSWER – Shirk Allah ke huqooq ka to rape insani huqooq ka issue hai
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya:
“Rape ek bada gunah hai, lekin shirk sabse bada gunah is liye hai kyun ke wo Allah ke haq ka khilaf hai. Aur ye Allah ka ikhtiyar hai ke wo kis gunah ko maaf kare aur kis ko nahi.”
Shirk wo zulm hai jo directly Allah ke khilaaf hai, aur Quran me clear hai:
“Allah shirk ko nahi maaf karega agar banda usi par mar gaya.”
DETAILED ANSWER – Hypothetical logic ka jawab, Mufti Yasir ke andaaz me
Mufti Yasir ne objector ke entire logic ko dismantle kar diya:
- Do khudaon ka tasavvur Islam me hai hi nahi.
Agar hypothetical ho bhi, to wo realistic aur possible hona chahiye. - Rape aur shirk dono gunah hain, lekin unki nature alag hai:
- Rape: Human rights ka violation hai. Agar victim maaf kar de, aur Allah chahe, to maafi ho sakti hai.
- Shirk: Creator ke haq ka violation hai. Quran me clear hai ke shirk unforgivable hai, agar insaan us par marte waqt tauba nahi karta.
- Yeh bhi clear hua: Islam me rape kabhi encourage nahi kiya gaya. Balki Islamic law me rape ke liye sakht saza di gayi hai.
Murti puja ko “chhoti galti” banana — Allah ke deen ko misunderstand karna hai. - Objector ne apni example me future ka ek aisa religion manaya jo kabhi exist hi nahi karta. Mufti ne kaha: “Aisi baat agar realistic hoti to ab tak aa chuki hoti. Ye aapki limited logic ka nateeja hai, na ke reality ka.”
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is logic me kya major galtiyan hain?
1. False Equivalence
Shirk aur rape dono alag category ke crimes hain — ek Allah ke against, dusra insano ke. Dono ko compare karna logically flawed hai.
2. Hypothetical Fallacy
Aisa religion jahan rape haram ho aur shirk halal — kabhi exist nahi kiya. Bina reality ke bas assumption banana fallacy hai.
3. Misunderstanding Divine Justice
Allah har gunah ka nature samajh kar hi decide karta hai — human court jaisa nahi hai jahan sab crimes ek scale par measure ho.
4. Strawman Argument
Islam kabhi nahi kehta ke rape “chhoti galti” hai. Is tarah ka twist Islam ki original teachings ko distort karna hai.
5. Appeal to Emotion
“Rape vs Murti Puja” ka comparison emotionally sensational hai, lekin logically incorrect.
6. Contradiction in Belief
Agar objector ye maanta hai ke har religion ka khuda ek hi hai, to phir usi khuda ke multiple contradictory rules ka logic fail ho jata hai.
7. Lack of Historical Evidence
Objector ka banaaya hua hypothetical religion — jis me rape forbidden ho aur shirk allowed ho — history me kabhi exist nahi kiya.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Har logic jo “mehnat se banaya gaya ho,” zaroori nahi ke sach ho
Mufti Yasir ne akhir me ek powerful line boli:
“Aap 3 mahine mehnat se ek logic laate ho, aur wo 3 minute me hawa ho jata hai.”
Islamic justice aur theology koi emotional ya hypothetical fantasy par base nahi hoti. Jo Allah ke haq ko todta hai — wo sabse bada gunah hai. Aur shirk wahi zulm-e-azeem hai. Uski severity ko rape ke scale par napna, na insaafi bhi hai aur logical dishonesty bhi.
