OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Quran sirf orally yaad hua, likha kyun nahi gaya?
Objection ye uthaya gaya ke agar Quran waqai Allah ka paighaam tha, to phir wo sirf zaban se hifz kyun hua? Kya likh kar usay record karna zyada logical nahi hota? Kuch log kehte hain ke Quran sirf yaadon ke zariye preserve hua, aur likhne ka process Prophet ﷺ ke baad shuru hua — is wajah se uski authenticity doubtful hai.
SHORT ANSWER – KYA Quran sirf yaadon me tha? Quran likhne ka short jawab
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Quran do parallel systems me preserve hua: ek oral (zabani) aur doosra written (tahreeri). Prophet ﷺ ke zamane me wahi ke likhne ke liye designated scribes (kuttab-e-wahi) the. Aur Hazrat Abu Bakr ke daur me ye likha gaya, gawah ke sath verify hua, aur officially state archive me mehfooz bhi kiya gaya.
DETAILED ANSWER – Quran ki tahreer ka mukammal logical jawab
- Dual Preservation: Quran ko sirf zaban se nahi, balke likh kar bhi mehfooz kiya gaya.
- Prophet ﷺ ke zamanay me Hazrat Zaid bin Thabit jese log wahi ko turant likh lete the.
- Hazrat Abu Bakr ke daur me, jab jang-e-Yamamah me 70+ huffaz shaheed hue, to pehli dafa Quran ko formal compiled manuscript banaya gaya.
- Verification Process: Har likhi hui ayat ko accept karne ke liye 2 authentic witnesses chahiye hote the — jinhone Prophet ﷺ ke saamne wahi likhi hui dekhi ho.
- Hazrat Umar R.A. is poore project ki supervision me the — aur ye sab kuch public space me hua, masjid-e-nabawi me.
- Is first compilation ko “Suhuf Abu Bakr” kaha gaya, jo later Hazrat Hafsa R.A. ke paas mehfooz raha.
- Later, Hazrat Usman R.A. ne is compilation ki master copies tayar karwa kar official Quranic Mushaf (Mushaf Imam) banwaya, jo aaj tak wahi hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Quran ki tahreer par objection ke 5 major flaws
1. False Assumption of Orality Only
Objection assume karta hai ke Quran sirf orally preserved tha, jabke historical evidence dual-preservation show karta hai.
2. Anachronistic Expectation
1400 saal pehle printing aur cheap paper ka concept nahi tha. Ek Quran likhne ke liye 200+ animals ki parchments chahiye hoti thi.
3. Ignoring Verification System
Her ayat ke sath do gawah required the — ye modern authentication system se bhi zyada strict tha.
4. Misunderstanding “Compilation”
Jo log kehte hain ke Quran Prophet ke baad compile hua, wo ye nahi samajhte ke likhne ka kaam to Prophet ke daur me hi chalu tha — compilation sirf arrange karne ka naam tha.
5. Selective Skepticism
Wahi log jo 2000 saal purani Greek texts ko accept kar lete hain bina isnad ke, wo Quran jese fully documented text ko reject karte hain — hypocrisy.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Quran sirf yaadon me nahi, har qadam pe likha bhi gaya
Mufti Yasir ne detail se samjhaya ke Quran ki tahreer koi baad ka kaam nahi tha — Prophet ﷺ ke daur se lekar Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, aur Usman ke daur tak har level pe Quran likha gaya, verify hua, aur officially archive hua. Aaj hamare paas jo Quran hai, wo sirf ek zubani riwayat nahi — wo state-level authenticated, gawaiyon se verified, aur publically recited kitab hai. Is se zyada transparency kisi religious scripture me nahi milti.
