OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Islamic Wars Bhi Land Ke Liye Hoti Thi?
Buddhist caller ne Mufti Yasir se compare kiya ke Mahabharat aur Hindu wars zameen ke liye hoti thi, jabke Islamic wars bhi allegedly land ya power ke liye ki gayi hongi. Unka kehna tha ke har religion ki history me violence hai, aur Islam bhi isse alag nahi. Ye ek common narrative hai jo Islam ko political expansion se jodta hai, na ke moral ya spiritual mission se.
SHORT ANSWER – Islam Ki Jangein Land Ya Belief Ke Liye?
Mufti Yasir ne clearly bataya ke Islam ki jangein aqeedah ke bunyad par hoti thi — yaani haq aur batil ke beech. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ne khud farmaya ke agar ek haath me suraj aur doosre me chaand rakh diya jaye, tab bhi main apna mission nahi chhorunga. Land ya power Islam ka goal nahi tha, sirf Allah ka paigham pohchana tha.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir Ka Jawab: Hindu Aur Islamic Wars Ka Farq
Mufti Yasir ne kaha ke Hindu dharm me Mahabharat jese wars clearly zameen, rajgaddi aur family disputes ke liye the. Lekin Islamic history me yeh factor nahi tha. Islam ki jangein Allah ke deen ke liye thi, aqeedah ke ikhlaqi uloom ko protect karne ke liye thi.
Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ko jab Quraysh ne hukumat dene ki offer ki, to unhone mana kar diya — kehkar ke chahe duniya ka sab kuch mil jaye, main Allah ka paigham nahi chhodunga. Ye clear evidence hai ke Islamic mission ka maqsad kabhi zameen nahi tha, sirf haqq ka izhar tha.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Islamic History Ko Political Expansion Kehne Ki Ghaltiyan
- False Comparison – Mahabharat jese wars zameen aur rajneeti ke liye the; Islamic battles aqeedah aur justice ke liye.
- Prophet’s Rejection of Power – Prophet ﷺ ne hukumat lene se mana kiya jab offer ki gayi, agar land aim hota to woh accept kar lete.
- Spiritual Mission Ignored – Islam ne belief system, justice aur akhirat ke concept ko center banaya, na ke duniya ko.
- Moral Superiority Denied – Islamic wars me strong ethical guidelines the, including rules for prisoners, non-combatants, aur environment.
- Simplistic View of Jihad – Jihad ko sirf war ya conquest tak limited kar dena Islamic concept ko distort karta hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Islam Ka Maqsad Kabhi Zameen Nahi Tha
Agar Islam ka maqsad zameen hota, to Prophet ﷺ power accept kar lete. Lekin unka jawab tha: “Main Allah ka paigham nahi chhod sakta.” Ye line Islam ki asli rooh ko represent karti hai — haq ki dawat, akhlaq, aur akhirat ka mission. Har religion ki history me violence ho sakta hai, lekin motive sab kuch badal deta hai.
Islam zameen nahi, insaan ki rooh ke liye aaya tha.
