Kya Science 5 Cheezen Jitna Ilm Rakh Sakti Hai?
Objection Explained
Atheist/ex-Muslim ne poocha: Quran kehta hai sirf Allah ko 5 cheezen ka ilm hai — jaise baarish kab hogi, maa ke womb me kya hai, etc. Lekin aaj kal science bhi bata deti hai ke kal rain hogi ya ladka hai ya ladki. To phir Allah ka “exclusive ilm” kahan gaya? Kya science ne sab kuch discover nahi kar liya?
Sirf Allah Ka Ilm — Science Ki Limit Ka Short Answer
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya: Science sirf prediction ya guess karti hai, 100% definite knowledge nahi hota. Quran me “ilm” se murad hai absolute knowledge — kab, kitni baarish hogi, kis jagah, kaunse second par, har cheez ka detail. Maa ke womb me sirf gender nahi, uski zindagi, rizq, kirdar — sab kuch sirf Allah hi jaanta hai. Science kabhi bhi yeh level ka knowledge nahi de sakti.
Science vs Allah Ka Ilm — Detailed Jawab
Detailed Answer
- Rain Prediction: Weather apps sirf guess karti hain. Forecast 100% accurate nahi hoti. Barish kab, kitni, kaunse second par hogi — yeh “definite knowledge” sirf Allah ke paas hai. Science bar bar galat sabit hoti hai.
- Womb Ka Ilm: Science gender predict kar sakti hai, lekin maa ke womb me kya hai — yeh sirf gender nahi. Allah ko pata hota hai:
- Bachcha kaisa hoga (achha ya bura)
- Uski zindagi kitni hai
- Rizq kitna milne wala hai
- Uski aulad aur nasl ka future
Science kabhi itna deep nahi ja sakti. Allah ne “ma fil arham” kaha, yani har detail — sirf Allah ke ilm me hai.
- Kulli Knowledge: Allah ka ilm “absolute & complete” hai — past, present, future, sab kuch. Science kabhi bhi sirf guess ya observation par base hoti hai.
- Misaal: Justin Bieber ki maa ka case — usne socha ladka hai, par uska future kya hoga, yeh kisi doctor ko nahi pata tha. Sirf Allah jaanta hai us bachche ka maqam, uski zindagi ka har pehlu.
Science vs Allah Ka Ilm — Objection Ki Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Prediction Ko Ilm Samajhna: Science ka prediction 100% nahi hota, bas estimate hai.
- Partial Knowledge: Science sirf kuch aspects jaanti hai, Allah har detail jaanta hai (past, present, future).
- Only Gender Pe Focus: Maa ke womb me sirf gender nahi, zindagi ka pura plan hai, wo sirf Allah jaanta hai.
- Ilm-e-Kulli vs Ilm-e-Juzwi: Allah ka ilm kul (complete) hai, science ka ilm juzwi (partial) hai.
- Ayat Ka Context Ignore Karna: Quran me jo 5 cheezen mention hain, unka context “absolute certainty” hai, na ke sirf physical observation.
Allah Ka Ilm, Science Ki Limit — Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Science jitni bhi advance ho jaye, wo sirf observation aur guess tak hi limited rahegi. Allah ka ilm har cheez ka asal, pure, complete aur absolute hai — har second, har jagah, har insaan ka detail. Jo log sirf physical cheezen dekh kar challenge karte hain, wo asli Quranic logic aur Allah ke maqam ko samajh nahi paate. Har insaan, har zindagi, har nasl — sab kuch Allah ke ilm me hai, science sirf surface tak hi ja sakti hai.