OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Allah ko Behayai NaPasand Hai, to Duniya me Behayai Kyun?
Ek atheist/ex-Muslim ne objection uthaya ke agar Allah ko behayai, murder, aur incest jese kaam nafrat angaz hain, to phir aise kaam duniya me exist kyun karte hain? Usne ye bhi poocha ke agar Allah ko ye kaam objectively buray lagte hain, to unhe banaya hi kyun gaya? Kya ye contradiction nahi hai?
(H2) SHORT ANSWER – Allah ne choice di, lekin har choice ka jawab bhi lena hoga
Allah ne insan ko free will di hai, taake test ho sake ke kaun sachai ka rasta chunta hai. Behayai, murder aur injustice buray hain – lekin unki maujoodgi ek test ka hissa hai. Har kaam ka hisaab hoga, lekin sirf insanon ke liye – janwaron par morality apply nahi hoti.
DETAILED ANSWER – Allah ne burai banayi nahi, choice di aur accountability bhi
Mufti Yasir ne point-by-point clear kiya:
- Allah ne shaitaan ko banaya, lekin uska kaam sirf waswasa dena hai. Har insan ke paas samajhne ki salahiyat hai ke kya sahi hai aur kya galat.
- Behayai, zulm, aur incest objectively buray hain – lekin iska matlab ye nahi ke koi insan ye kaam kar hi nahi sakta. Log aksar apni fitrat ke khilaf bhi kaam karte hain.
- Misal: Ek baba 10 saal se haath upar kiye baitha hai – jabke fitrat ke khilaf hai. Log physical discomfort bhi choose kar lete hain.
- Allah ne sirf insan ko accountability ke liye chuna hai. Janwar agar incest ya violence karein, to unke liye na sawaab hai, na azaab.
- Morality ka scale sirf insano ke liye hai. Janwaron ko sirf biological lens se samjha jaa sakta hai, moral lens se nahi.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Atheist ke reasoning me logical mistakes
Fallacy 1: Confusing Creation with Approval Aise kaamon ki existence ka matlab ye nahi ke Allah unse razi hai. Allah ne test create kiya hai, na ke burai.
Fallacy 2: Moral Framework ko Janwaron par Apply Karna Janwar moral agents nahi hote. Unki koi accountability nahi hoti.
Fallacy 3: Misunderstanding Divine Like/Dislike Allah ki pasand ka matlab reward hai, aur napasand ka matlab punishment. Ye system sirf insano par apply hota hai.
Fallacy 4: Expecting a Perfect World in a Test-Based Life Duniya test ka maqam hai – har cheez perfect nahi hogi. Agar burai hoti hi na, to test ka matlab hi nahi banta.
Fallacy 5: Equating Biology with Ethics Biological behavior aur moral behavior ek nahi hote. Ek janwar ka act moral ya immoral decide nahi karta.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Allah ne test banaya, aur har test ka result hoga
Insano ko free will di gayi, aur uska har use record ho raha hai. Janwaron ki example dekar morality ko challenge nahi kiya ja sakta, kyunke morality ka scale insani samajh aur action par based hai. Jo kaam Allah ko na-pasand hain, unka hisaab akhirat me hoga — aur wahi justice ka asli manzar hoga. Har shakhs ko yeh samajhna hoga ke choice dena aur approval dena ek hi cheez nahi hain.