Objection Explained – Agar Allah Dil Band Kar De To Hidayat Kaise Mile?
Ek atheist ne objection uthaya: agar Allah ne Makkah ke mushrikon ke dil par mohar lagadi thi (as per Quran), to phir wo log kabhi iman kaise la sakte the? Aur jab Nabi ﷺ ne Makkah ko fateh kiya, tabhi kyun unka dil khula? Kya ye sab talwar ke zor par tha? Agar pehle hi dil khol deta, to iman pehle le aate.
SHORT ANSWER – Allah Mohar Kyun Lagata Hai? Simple Jawab
Allah kisi ke dil par bina wajah mohar nahi lagata. Quran ke mutabiq, jo log haq saamne aane ke bawajood bhi arrogance (takabbur) ki wajah se reject karte hain, unhi ke dil Allah band karta hai. Hidayat ka darwaza un logon ke liye khulta hai jo sincere aur open-hearted hote hain — jaise Madina ke log.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir Ne Kya Samjhaya?
Mufti Yasir ne do cheezon par focus kiya:
- Slow Growth Is Not Failure:
Nabi ﷺ ne 11 saal tak Makkah me dawat di, lekin sirf 200 logon ne iman laaya. Ye failure nahi, organic growth ka natural process tha. Har great project dheere dheere hi grow karta hai. - Sealing of Hearts Explained:
Quran (Surah Mu’min 40:35) me Allah ne kaha:
“Kazzalika yatba’ullahu ‘ala qalbi kulli mutakabbirin jabbaar”
(Allah mohar lagata hai har us shakhs ke dil par jo arrogance karta hai).
Yani Allah unke dil band karta hai jo haq ko jaan bujh kar reject karte hain — takabbur, tribal bias, ya stubbornness ki wajah se.
Madina ke mushrikeen ne jab Nabi ﷺ ka paighaam suna, to wo open-minded aur sincere log the. Isliye Allah ne unka dil hidayat ke liye khol diya — bina kisi jang ke. Lekin Makkah ke leaders arrogant aur hostile the, jinhone zulm kiya, haq ka mazaak banaya, aur apni izzat ko haq se upar rakha.
OBJECTION FLAWS – “Dil Par Mohar” Argument Ke Logical Errors
1. Cause-Effect Reversal:
Objection ye maanta hai ke pehle mohar lagi, fir unhone reject kiya. Jabke Quran ke mutabiq unhone pehle haq ka inkar kiya, isliye mohar lagi.
2. Emotional Appeal Fallacy:
Talwar aur conquest ka zikr sirf emotional angle banane ke liye hota hai. Jabke iman Madina me bina kisi talwar ke aaya.
3. Oversimplification:
Hidayat sirf Allah ka action nahi hota. Insaan ka ikhtiyar (free will) bhi usme shamil hota hai. Har koi yeh deserve nahi karta.
4. Ignoring Quranic Context:
Quran ne specific logon ka zikr kiya hai jinke dil par mohar lagi — mutakabbir jabbaar (arrogant tyrants). Sab log isme shamil nahi.
5. Selective History Use:
Objector Madina ke musalmaan hone ki process ko ignore karta hai — jahan iman sirf dawat aur akhlaaq se phaila, na ke talwar se.
6. Bias Fallacy:
Objector ka assumption hai ke agar unke ancestor ke khilaf bola gaya to wo insult hai. Jabke Nabi ﷺ ne apne hi ancestors ke shirk ko expose kiya — out of truth, not insult.
7. False Moral Equivalence:
Agar Nabi ﷺ apne hi ancestors ke shirk ko highlight karein, to wo insaaf hai, not bias. Jo galat hai, usko pehchanna hi imandari hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Mohar Aur Hidayat Dono Insaan Ke Amal Se Judi Hai
Allah har dil par mohar nahi lagata — sirf un par jo sach jaan kar bhi arrogance me reject karte hain. Madina ke log jab sincere niyyat se aaye, to Allah ne unke dil khol diye. Hidayat ek reward hai — jo usi ko milti hai jo use chahne ka haq rakhta hai. Nafrat, bias, aur ego lekar chalne wale log sirf blame karte hain — lekin khud ko change nahi karte.
