OBJECTION EXPLAINED – “Main Naik Hoon, Lekin Allah Ko Nahi Maanta”
Ek sanatani objector ne ye kaha ke wo poori zindagi achhe kaam karta aaya hai — kisi ka bura nahi kiya, kanoon nahi toda — phir bhi Islam ke mutabiq uska anjaam dozakh kyun hoga sirf is liye ke usne Allah ko nahi maana? Uska kehna tha ke agar usne insaniyat ka khayal rakha, to akhir uska kya kasoor?
SHORT ANSWER – KYA ALLAH SIRF MUSALMANON KO JANNAT DETA HAI?
Achha insaan banna zaroori hai, lekin kafi nahi. Agar koi apne parents, society aur desh ke saath insaaf karta hai, lekin khud us Khaliq ke saath nahi — jiske naam par ye sab insaaf define hua hai — to usse ‘just’ nahi kaha jaa sakta. Aur agar koi Allah ke saath zulm kare, to uska anjaam azaab hi hoga.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ne kaise toda “Naik Sanatani” wala logic?
Mufti Yasir ne logically prove kiya ke:
- Jo banda apni wife, bachchon, aur society ke saath insaaf karta hai, lekin apne Khaliq ke saath nahi — wo just nahi, zalim kehlata hai.
- Islam ye nahi kehta ke insaniyat chhod do — Islam kehta hai ke insaniyat ke peechay Creator ka haq bhi recognize karo.
- Allah ne sab ko free will di hai — jab tak banda khud accept nahi karta, Allah zabardasti iman nahi dalta.
- Agar aapko duniya me paida hone ki jagah choose karne ka ikhtiyar nahi mila, to ye bhi ek test ka part hai — lekin sachai ki talaash har insaan ke andar naturally daal di gayi hai.
- Quran kehta hai: “La yukallifullahu nafsan illa wus‘aha” — Allah kisi par uski capacity se zyada zimmedari nahi daalta.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is Logic Me Kya Kya Galat Tha?
- Partial Justice Fallacy
– Sirf society ke rules follow karna poora insaaf nahi. Agar Allah jise sab cheezon ka Creator maana ja raha hai usi ko ignore kiya jaye, to insaaf incomplete hai. - Selective Morality
– Jab baat wife ya neighbor ki ho to morality important, lekin jab Allah ki baat aaye to ignore? Yeh double standard hai. - Emotional Appeal
– “Maine kisi ka bura nahi kiya” sirf ek emotional statement hai — objective truth ka standard nahi. - False Universalism
– Ye maanna ke sab dharmon ka maqsad same hai aur sab raste jannat le jaate hain, logically flawed hai. Har deen ka salvation model alag hai. - Ignorance Excuse Fallacy
– “Main to Hindu ghar me paida hua” — ye excuse nahi banta, kyunki duniya bhar ke log religion change karke Islam accept karte hain. - Spiritual Delusion
– Meditations aur lights dekhna Allah ka deedar nahi hota. Islam me Allah ko duniya me dekhna namumkin hai. - Conceptual Confusion
– Apne “god” ko light kehna aur uski body reject karna, phir usi light ko ultimate reality kehna — ye contradictory spiritual logic hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Naik Insaan Ya Waqai Just?
Aapka asal imtihan sirf achhe kaam nahi — balki yeh pehchan lena bhi hai ke aapko banane wala kaun hai. Agar aap sab ke saath insaaf karein, lekin us Rab ke saath nahi jiska haq sabse pehle aap par hai — to aap “naik” nahi, “na-insaaf” kehlate hain.