OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Khajoor ke Darakht ke Rone ka Waqia Fake Hai?
Ek atheist ne ye objection uthaya ke Sahih Bukhari ki ek Hadith me likha hai ke Nabi ﷺ ke liye jab mimbar banaya gaya to jis khajoor ke darakht ke paas wo pehle khutbah dete the, wo darakht rona shuru kar gaya. Objector ne is baat ka mazaak banaya aur kaha ke ek tree ka rona impossible hai. Unka kehna tha ke agar aisa waqia sach hota to dobara aaj bhi repeat hota.
SHORT ANSWER – Khajoor ke Darakht ke Rone ka SHORT me Jawab
Allah jisne darakht banaye hain, wo unhe jab chahe kisi bhi tarah react karwa sakta hai — rola bhi sakta hai. Hum limited power wale log hai, lekin Allah ke liye koi bhi cheez impossible nahi, jab tak usme contradiction na ho. Aur science bhi maanta hai ke plants react karte hain, unka stress response hota hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Kya Tree Ka Rona Scientific ya Logical Hai?
Mufti Yasir ne is objection ka jawab do angles se diya:
- Theological point: Allah ke liye koi bhi cheez impossible nahi jab tak usme logical contradiction na ho. Agar Allah ne ek tree ko aawaz dene ki qudrat di, to usme kya mushkil hai? Jab Allah ne humans ko tongue aur expression diya, to tree ko bhi de sakta hai.
- Logical definition of “Impossible”: Impossible sirf wahi hota hai jo kisi bhi form me imaginable na ho — jaise 2+2=5 ya unlimited power ka limited ban jana. Tree ka rona is category me nahi aata.
- Scientific evidence: Modern research (CNN aur dusre sources) ke mutabiq plants stress me ultrasonic sounds nikalte hain. Ye “crying” nahi to aur kya hai? Toh Hadith me jo bat hai, wo science se conflict nahi karti.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Khajoor ke Darakht ke Rone wale Objection me 5 Logical Ghaltiyan
1. Limited Power se Unlimited Power ka Comparison:
Objector ne apni limited ability ko Allah ki unlimited ability se compare kiya, jo logic ka basic flaw hai.
2. Past Events ka Present me Repeat Na Hone ka Illogical Standard:
Ye kehna ke agar koi waqia ab repeat nahi ho raha to wo hua hi nahi — is logic se to Mahabharat, Ramayan, World War sab fake ban jayenge.
3. Selective Skepticism:
Objector scientific news paper reports (jaise Ukraine war) bina witness kiye maanta hai, lekin Hadith reject kar deta hai sirf isliye ke wo personally nahi dekha.
4. False Definition of Impossible:
Objector ne “impossible” ka matlab hi ghalat liya. Har wo cheez jo insaan nahi kar sakta, wo impossible nahi hoti — sirf contradictory cheeze impossible hoti hain.
5. Scientific Ignorance:
Science ne ye prove kiya hai ke plants stress me reaction show karte hain, lekin objector ne bina research kiye tree ke crying ko impossible maan liya.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Yeh Waqia Logic aur Science Dono se Possible Hai
Jab Allah jise chahe, jise chahe uske through apni qudrat ka izhar kar sakta hai, to ek tree ka rona koi ajeeb baat nahi. Problem sirf tab hoti hai jab hum apne limited logic se Allah ki power ko judge karne lagte hain. Jo insaan khud ek miracle hai, wo agar doosre miracles ko fake samjhe to yeh sirf uski understanding ki kami hai.
