OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Main Galat Mazhab Me Paida Hua To Sacchai Kaise Dhoondhun?
Ek honest truth-seeker ne question uthaya: agar kisi insaan ka paida hona hi kisi specific religion me ho gaya — jaise Hindu, Christian ya Jew — to kya uska Islam tak pahunchna possible hai? Aur agar kisi ko Islam ka sahi version kabhi mila hi nahi, to kya uski accountability hogi?
SHORT ANSWER – Sacchai dhoondhne wala akeli aql se bhi Allah tak pahunch sakta hai
Mufti Yasir ke mutabiq, agar koi insan apni research aur fitrat se ye samajh jaye ke ek hi Allah hai jiska koi shareek nahi, to uski niyyat aur koshish ka reward Allah deta hai. Agar us tak Islam ka asal chehra nahi pahucha, to uski accountability Allah ke ilm aur insaaf ke mutabiq hogi.
(H2) DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka step-by-step logic
- Agar kisi ne khud apni aql se yeh pehchaan liya ke khuda ek hai aur uski koi tasveer ya avatar nahi ho sakta, to yeh pehla step hai.
- Hinduism aur Christianity dono God ke human form me aane ka aqeeda rakhte hain — is contradiction ki wajah se ye options reject ho jaate hain.
- Judaism ek exclusive race-based belief ban chuka hai — jisme outsider ke liye salvation ka concept hi nahi.
- Sirf Islam woh religion hai jo universal hai, God ko beyond human form maanta hai, aur har insaan ke liye hidayat ka message deta hai.
- Agar kisi ko misinformation milti hai, aur phir bhi wo sirf Allah ki tawheed tak pahunch jata hai — to uski niyyat aur fitrat Allah ki nazar me qabil-e-qadr hoti hai (Imam Ghazali ka reference).
OBJECTION FLAWS – Sochne wale ke reasoning me logical confusion
Fallacy 1: Assuming Birthplace = Final Truth Paida hone ki jagah haq ko define nahi karti — haq dhoondhne ki niyyat karti hai.
Fallacy 2: Confusing Misinformation with Rejection Islam ka sahi chehra kisi tak na pahunchna, aur usko reject kar dena — dono alag cheezein hain.
Fallacy 3: Limiting Guidance to Book Access Only Fitrat aur aql bhi guidance ka source hai — sirf kitab tak limited rehna zaroori nahi.
Fallacy 4: Delaying Action Despite Clarity Agar ek shakhs ko Islam logical lag raha hai, to “aur sochne” ke bahane banana apne upar zulm hai.
Fallacy 5: Applying Morality Without Considering Context Accountability ka base knowledge aur access par hota hai — aur Allah har shakhs ko usi basis par judge karega.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Jab raste ka pata lag jaye to pehla qadam lena farz ban jata hai
Mufti Yasir ne emotional aur logical dono tareeqon se samjhaya: agar aap sach ke raaste tak pahunch gaye ho, aur aapko pata hai ke Islam hi wo raasta hai, to delay karna khatarnaak ho sakta hai. Zindagi ka bharosa nahi, aur agar maut aa gayi to Allah poochega: jab sab kuch samajh gaya tha, to kabool kyun nahi kiya? Hidayat ek fazl hai — lekin uspe amal karna zimmedari hai.
