Kya Torah Aur Injil Bilkul Bhi Tabdeel Nahin Hui?
Objection Explained
Ek critic ne Surah Aal-e-Imran ki ayat 78 ka hawala diya aur kaha ke Quran khud keh raha hai ke Torah aur Injil me sirf “misinterpretation” hua hai, tabdeeli nahi. Is base par usne Muslim aqeede ko contradict kiya jo kehta hai ke pehle ki kitaabon me tahrif (fabrication) hua hai.
Quran Ka Kya Kehna Hai?
Short Answer
Surah Aal-e-Imran ayat 78 me likha hai ke kuch log “kitaab likhte hain apni taraf se, aur kehte hain yeh Allah ka kalam hai.” Yeh lafzi tabdeeli ka open evidence hai — sirf misinterpretation nahi. To Quran khud tahrif bil-lafz ka aqeeda confirm karta hai.
Mufti Yasir Ka Jawab
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne tafsir Ibn-e-Kaseer aur classical sources se ye points clear kiye:
- Agar sirf misinterpretation hoti to Allah yeh na kehta ke “kitaab likhi ja rahi hai apni taraf se.”
- Torah aur Injil Allah ki taraf se zaroor thi, aur unpe imaan lana wajib hai. Lekin “amal” nahi ho sakta, kyunki unme tabdeeli ho chuki hai.
- Imaan aur amal do alag branches hain. Jaise Allah ek hai — is par imaan lana hai, amal nahi. Waise hi un kitaabon par imaan hai, amal nahi.
- Agar asli version hota to Quran kehta “Torah/Injil par amal karo,” lekin kehta hai “imaan lao,” jo sabit karta hai ke amal laayak version nahi raha.
Objection Mein Kitni Ghaltiyan Thi?
Objection Flaws
- Misquote: Usne ayat ka sirf half part quote kiya, poora meaning chhupa diya.
- Tafsir ignore ki: Ibn-e-Kaseer aur Ibn Abbas ka tafsir clearly “tahrif bil-lafz” mention karta hai.
- Belief vs Action confuse kiya: Imaan lana aur amal karna ko mix kar diya.
- Old vs corrupted text ka fark na samjha: Asli kitaabein thi, lekin logon ne badal di.
- Logical contradiction: Usne apne hi reference se apne point ko deny kar diya.
Quran Pe Kyun Imaan, Baqi Pe Sirf Itihaat?
Final Thoughts
Muslim aqeeda yeh hai ke Allah ne Torah aur Injil bhi bheji thi — lekin unme logon ne tabdeeli kar di. Is wajah se unpe sirf imaan rakha jata hai, amal nahi. Quran protected hai, baqi kitaabein nahi. Critic ne jo ayat quote ki — usi ne uska point collapse kar diya.