Time, God & Sanatani Fallacies

Kya Allah Time Se Pehle Tha Ya Time Eternal Hai?

Objection Explained
Ek Sanatani objector ne claim kiya ke time ko Allah ne create nahi kiya ho sakta. Uske mutabiq har creation time ke andar hoti hai, aur agar time hi nahi tha to creation ka idea hi illogical hai. Usne argument diya ke agar Allah tha aur time nahi tha, to “tha” ka word khud contradiction ban jata hai, kyunki “tha” ek tense hai aur tense sirf tabhi hota hai jab time exist karta ho. Is base par usne bola ke ya to Allah aur time dono eternal hain, ya fir ye poori logic collapse ho jati hai.

Kya Allah Ne Time Ko Banaya? Ka Short Aur Clear Jawab

Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Allah eternal hai aur time uski creation hai. Jab hum kehte hain “Allah tha aur time nahi tha”, to “tha” humari human language ka limitation hai — logic ka flaw nahi. Allah ka wujood time se pehle bhi tha, lekin wo “pehle” humare sense ka nahi, metaphysical level par hai. Time Allah ke liye mohtaj nahi, balke uska makhlooq hai.

Allah Aur Time Ka Taluq – Detailed Jawab Mufti Yasir Ki Logic Ke Saath

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke:

• Allah eternal hai, lekin time ek creation hai. Creation ko start karne ke liye Allah ko kisi external time ka mohtaj nahi hona padta.
• Objector ne kaha ke agar Allah tha aur time nahi tha, to “tha” ka lafz tense dikhata hai. Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke yeh linguistic limitation hai, logical contradiction nahi.
• Tenses human language me hotay hain, Allah par nahi. Hamari language time-bound hai, Allah nahi.
• Takaddum (precedence) zamani nahi, wujudi hoti hai. Allah ka wujood time ke bagair bhi logically possible hai.
• Jab objector ne kaha ke time bhi Allah ka part hai, to Mufti Yasir ne poocha: agar tum Allah ka part ho, to kya tum Allah ki marzi ke khilaf kuch kar sakte ho? Free will ka hona proof karta hai ke hum Allah ka part nahi hain.

Time Eternal Hai? Is Objection Ke Logical Flaws

Objection Flaws

1. Linguistic Confusion as Logic: “Allah tha” ko contradiction kehna ek language ka masla hai, na ke real logic ka.
2. Contradiction in Unity Claim: Time ko Allah ka part bolkar phir usse alag tareeqe se describe karna self-contradictory hai.
3. Infinity Fallacy: Objector ne kaha ke 1947 ke baad aur 2000 ke baad ke time sets unequal hain — Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke infinity ko compare karna mathematically incorrect hai.
4. Free Will Conflict: Agar har cheez Allah ka part hoti, to koi Allah ki marzi ke khilaf amal nahi karta. Magar reality me hota hai.
5. Applying Physics to God: Physics ke rules sirf physical world pe lagte hain. Allah unpar apply nahi hota.
6. One-Dimensional Thinking: Sirf temporal “before/after” ko use karke Allah ko define karna flawed hai. Wujudi precedence ko samajhna zaruri hai.
7. Blind Physical Deduction: Sirf physical duniya dekh kar metaphysical conclusions banana limited aur inaccurate approach hai.

Kya Insani Logic Allah Ke Beyond Concepts Ko Samajh Sakti Hai?

Final Thoughts
Allah ka wujood har limit, har time aur har space se pare hai. Jab hum usse define karne ki koshish karte hain apni language aur logic se, to hum khud confuse ho jate hain. Mufti Yasir ne is debate me ye sabit kiya ke Allah time ka creator hai — aur jo argument “contradiction” ke naam par uthaya gaya tha, wo sirf language aur limited logic ka misuse tha. Sachai yeh hai ke Allah par na time apply hota hai, na physics, na human contradiction rules.