Kya Tawheed Aur Murti Pooja Dono Sahi Ho Sakte Hain?

Objection Explained
Ek caller ne claim kiya ke “main kisi religion ka follower nahi hoon, main bas logically sochta hoon.” Usne kaha ke Islam me shirk galat hai aur Hinduism me tawheed galat hai — matlab dono apne hisaab se sahi hain. Jab Mufti Yasir ne poocha ke “agar dono opposite cheezein hain to kaun sahi hai?”, to wo jawab dene ke bajaye confused ho gaya aur apne hi contradictions me phans gaya.

Kya Tawheed Aur Murti Pooja Dono Sahi Ho Sakte Hain?

Short Answer
Tawheed (sirf ek Allah ki ibadat) aur shirk (murti pooja) ek dusre ke mukhalif aqeede hain. Dono ko ek saath sahi nahi kaha ja sakta. Agar aap logically soch rahe hain, to aapko clear stance lena hoga — neutral banne ke naam par contradiction accept kar lena, logic nahi hota.

Kya Tawheed Aur Murti Pooja Dono Sahi Ho Sakte Hain?

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne is so-called “neutral thinker” ke contradictions expose kiye:

1. Tawheed vs Shirk: Caller ne kaha Islam me shirk galat hai aur Hinduism me tawheed — dono alag cheezein hain. Jab yeh dono core beliefs ek dusre ke opposite hain, to dono ko “sahi” kehna impossible hai.
2. Avoiding Clear Answers: Jab Mufti Yasir ne repeatedly poocha ke Hindu dharm me kya galat hai, to caller ne kisi bhi scripture ya belief ko point out nahi kiya. Sirf guru aur baba ke incidents bataye — jo irrelevant thay.
3. Personal Deflection: Jab logic fail hua, to caller ne khud ko “insaan hi galat hai” keh kar apni zimmedari se nikalne ki koshish ki — lekin Islam pe criticism jari rakha.
4. Selective Judgement: Hinduism me sab kuch sahi kehna, aur Islam ke core beliefs (shirk ke khilaf aqeeda) pe objection uthana — ye kisi bhi angle se fair ya logical nahi tha.
5. Mufti Yasir’s Response: Unhone clear kiya ke shirk sabse bada zulm hai, jiska koi justification Islam me nahi ho sakta. Aur agar aap kisi system ko sahi keh rahe hain, to uska amal bhi follow karna chahiye — warna wo sirf lafzon ka khel hai.

Kya Tawheed Aur Murti Pooja Dono Sahi Ho Sakte Hain?

Objection Flaws

1. Logical Contradiction: Tawheed aur shirk dono ko ek saath sahi kehna clear contradiction hai.
2. No Religious Text Evidence: Caller ne apne claims ke support me koi bhi ved ya granth ka hawala nahi diya.
3. Personal Character Shield: Apne aap ko “non-religious” keh kar criticism ko neutral dikhana — ek deceptive tactic hai.
4. Selective Objection Bias: Islam ke strong monotheism par attack, lekin polytheism ka defense — double standard.
5. Aman aur logic ka misuse: Peaceful tone aur “main logic se sochta hoon” kehna tab meaningless ho jata hai jab reasoning hi contradict kar rahi ho.
6. Shirk ko Normalize Karna: Islamophobic framing me shirk ko “ek option” kehna, Islam ke aqeede ka open violation hai.
7. Avoiding Accountability: Jab jawab dena mushkil hua, to khud ko “confused” ya “bas sochne wala” kehkar exit lena — debate ka unjust close hai.

Kya Tawheed Aur Murti Pooja Dono Sahi Ho Sakte Hain?

Final Thoughts
Aaj kal kai log “main kisi dharm ka nahi hoon” kehkar Islam pe sawal uthate hain, lekin jab unse apne views ka logical hisaab liya jaye, to wo contradictions me phans jaate hain. Mufti Yasir ne sirf aqeeda nahi defend kiya — unhone bataya ke agar aap haq ke talib hain, to aapko shirk aur tawheed me se ek ko choose karna hoga. Har cheez ko sahi kehna asal me sach ko chhupana hota hai.